Change in judging?

Voici un commentaire de "Dressage Direct" ...intéressant!

The overall questions about this Aachen CDI 2005 were also about how much the general basics in dressage should be decisive in the arena. Chairman of the judges Dr Volker Moritz was very outspoken when he said that he was very unhappy because of some of the turbulent questions of Aachen around dressage definitely were caused by too much differences in the judging.
“The conceptual basics of things like regularity, looseness, the swinging back, the collection, they all have to be more clear and decisive for any judge in any test. We propose some measures to improve the judging, at least for the WEG in Aachen next year”, Dr Volker Moritz as the chairman of the International Dressage Judges Club IDJC promised.
“Also the fact that less experienced judges can judge a big CDIO like Aachen, should definitely be excluded for the future. Furthermore we propose to judge more shows together going towards a championship”, Dr Volker Moritz stated

(par Christian Carde)

Going through the list, it appears that most of all the lowest notes are given by Mariette Withages, president of the dressage commitee of the FEI ... and member of the commitee of honour of our association.
Proof that ranking according to the rules can change the scores and this reinforces Allege-Ideal in it´s aim to obtain a strict application of the Art 401 in dressage competition!
Let´s hope Mrs Withages keeps on doing a good job for the sake of the horses and horsemanship in general. Thanks to her!
---------------
En parcourant la liste, il apparait que la plupart des notes les plus basses aient été attribuées par Mariette Withages, présidente de la commission de dressage à la FEI ... et membre du comité d´honneur de notre association.
Preuve que les notes calquées sur le règlement peuvent changer les résultats et confortent Allege-Ideal dans son objectif d´obtenir le strict respect de l´article 401 dans la compétition de dressage. Espérons que Mme Whithages continuera d´enfoncer le clou pour le bien-être des chevaux et de l´équitation en général.Merci à elle!

(par pilar)